Kim Savage’s Beautiful Broken Girls is riveting but flawed

Beautiful Broken GirlsBEAUTIFUL BROKEN GIRLS by Kim Savage, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, Feb. 21, 2017, Hardcover, $17.99 (young adult)

In Beautiful Broken Girls you meet Mira and Francesca Cillo are perfect by most people’s standards. They’re beautiful and popular, albeit overprotected by their father. They might be a little odd, but people don’t seem to mind too much. The world seemingly revolves around them until the night they disappear, drowning themselves in the quarry lake.

Days after Mira and Francesca’s deaths, Ben receives a letter from Mira. The letter sends Ben on a quest to find notes in the places where the two of them touched. You see, even though the Cillo girls appeared untouchable, Ben had broken through. He touched Mira’s palm, her hair, her chest, her cheek, her lips, her throat and her heart. As Ben collects Mira’s notes, he comes to realize how little of the girls he really knew. The Cillo’s had their secrets, and some secrets are better left alone.

Beautiful Broken Girls unfolds in the present and the past. You get to know the girls as they interact with friends and family, and Ben as he struggles to accept the position Mira has put him in.

I didn’t particularly like or care about the characters in Beautiful Broken Girls. Francesca seemed over the top; Mira too complacent; and Ben just kind of a mess. And yet, I couldn’t put the book down. It’s an unusual conundrum. I usually don’t spend my time on characters I don’t find compelling, but in this case, it’s the work as a whole that stuck with me.

What it comes down to is the masterful storytelling of Kim Savage. I read her novel After The Woods, in one sitting. The same is true of Beautiful Broken Girls. Kim has a way of capturing you and pulling you along for the ride, even if you don’t like where it’s going — as was the case with After The Woods — or question motives — Beautiful Broken Girls.

There’s a lot going on in Beautiful Broken Girls, and context can be slow in coming at times, but it’s still a strong mystery. Though I found myself swept up in Kim Savage’s story, it’s not one I’m likely to reread. I’d check this one out from the library before purchasing to make sure it’s something you really want to own.

© 2017, Cracking the Cover. All rights reserved.


About Author

Jessica Harrison is the main reviewer behind Cracking the Cover. Prior to creating Cracking the Cover, Jessica worked as the in-house book critic for the Deseret News, a daily newspaper in Salt Lake City. Jessica also worked as a copy editor and general features writer for the paper. Following that, Jessica spent two years with an international company as a social media specialist. She is currently a freelance writer/editor. She is passionate about reading and giving people the tools to make informed decisions in their own book choices.

Leave A Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.